FLAVORS

Vanilla
chocolate
strawberry
cookies & Cream
Mint chip
Butter Pecan
Rum Raisin
Coffee Chip
Banana PUdding
Toasted Coconut
Vanilla Chip
Cookie Dough
Pralines & Cream
Sundae Best
Smurfs
Cotton Candy
 

Cake Batter
Birthday Cake
Pistachio
Cinnamon Bun
Salted Caramel
Chocolate Peanut Butter
Boston Cream Pie
Strawberry Oreo
Black RasPberry Chip
Mounds
Lemon Ginger Snap
Black cherry
Creamy Peanut Butter
Peanut Butter Oreo
S'mores
Chocolata
'O'Mazing Oreo
Snickers

Creamsicle
Kit Kat
Mississippi Mud
French Pastry Cheesecake
Curious George
Peaches & Cream
Maple Chip
Apple Pie
Tiramisu
Pumpkin Pecan Swirl
Peppermint Patty
Gingerbread Man
Strawberry Lemonade Ice
Bing Cherry Ice
Lemon Ice
Mango Ice

These are just some of the 130 flavors we sell!

All of our flavors are available as Milkshakes, Malteds, Egg Creams,  Sundaes, & Banana Splits!

Specialties


Ice Cream Cakes

 
FivePennies_2_01.jpg
 

Our homemade ice cream cakes are perfect for any special occasion 

Available in four sizes (6”, 7”, 9”, and 10”), our standard round cakes are made with vanilla and chocolate frozen custard, with a layer of crunchies in the middle. 

Additional sizes and flavors are available upon request for custom orders! 

We keep our freezers stocked with a small selection of standard cakes for pick-up daily, based on availability.  For detailed information on pricing and ordering, please contact the store.  

**Please provide at least three days notice for custom orders**

**Flavors available for custom orders based on availability at time of order**

 

 

ICE CREAM PIES

 
FivePennies_2_03.jpg
 

We make our ice cream pies by filling a graham cracker crust with our homemade hard ice cream. 

Made in two sizes (9” and 10”), these frozen pies are a holiday favorite.  While a small selection of 9” pies are available in the store daily, we recommend custom ordering your favorite flavor for a unique treat!

*Please provide at least three days notice for custom orders*

**Flavors available for custom orders based on availability at time of order**